The volume collects texts of “readings” held by Fr. Giussani on some authors who were dear to him and, in the appendix, on some films; they are occasional readings and therefore far from a critical-literary attempt, but the deep observation and empathy they show get to the heart of the work or author that is taken into consideration. The methodological hypothesis is that genius, when most fully expressed, comes to prophesy the level in which all reality consists—that is, Christ.
Giacomo Leopardi at the Culmination of His Prophetic Genius
The text is also an autobiographical glimpse of Fr. Giussani; in recounting his early encounter with Leopardi (age twelve), Fr. Giussani targets the most compelling question of life, “[since] a man is not defined by his own limitation, [since] he is not defined by what he is, [since] attraction to reality remains open, this means the inevitable affirmation of a presence, of an ultimate answer. This affirming an ultimate positive presence is so implicit in reason, understood as consciousness of the real, that Leopardi eventually recognized it.” This reading path shows and documents that Leopardi, in the wake of his hymn To Aspasia, wrote To His Woman as a “sublime prayer,” in a “balanced and powerful” moment, and became a prophet, “in the literal sense of the word,” of the Incarnation.
A Reading of Pascoli on the Ultimate Destiny
This reading deals with Giovanni Pascoli’s Primi poemetti, an author that Fr. Giussani continually read and pondered; his way of reading is well described in the first lines, “Genius cannot be expressed except—even unwillingly—by prophesying.” The first point of emphasis concerns the characteristic of Pascoli’s poetry whereby a “small banality” becomes a “sign” and thus a “cosmic symbol”—reading his poems “The Great Aspiration” and “The Book,” Fr. Giussani introduces and begins to unveil Pascoli’s metaphysics, that is “Pascoli’s image of the ultimate human things.” This image of an “ultimate destiny,” traced in his Primi poemetti, reveals a deeply rooted religiosity, even if concealed from the gaze of a superficial reader. It is primarily based around two issues—a great human loneliness in the universe, infinite and silent, and a great need for forgiveness and companionship. Pascoli’s investigation tacitly comes to imply “something Other” that needs to be manifested in life, something else that is not just a realized human ethic, but springs from an “unknown quid [...], from this positivity, although mysterious.”
The Drama of Clemente Rebora
The main thematic values of Rebora’s expression are soon traced by Fr. Giussani at the beginning of his reading, “an all-embracing nature filled with a longing desire, colliding with the limit (death) and finding the eternal therein.” Rebora is presented above all, even before his priesthood, as a “pauper evangelicus,” as a good man, filled with positivity in the face of the mystery of things, who senses that man “is, and does not ‘invent’ himself,” cooperating with the mysterious reality before which he is placed. Thus, through his intelligence, his words, his body, man cooperates with his understanding of reality, not just with some “fragments of reality, fragments performed according to his own preconceptions, or to estimates.” From this human position, Rebora’s path becomes “a tension to remove the veils of this concealment as much as possible, a tension towards God.” The reading documents, through various Frammenti lirici and later poems, the question that “spasms the soul in all its pangs” and the certainty of an answer, “it will come if I resist” (if I am consistent with my nature, as Fr. Giussani comments), and poetry as mission in respect to the reader, “Thou, reader, in the brief sound / That makes immensity a tiny grain / Thou hearest the meaning of the world: / And may your assenting be of help.”
The Problem of Conversion in Ada Negri
Through this reading Fr. Giussani aims to “help us understand how conversion takes place in Ada Negri, that is, the discovery that everything is an act of love, that everything is united by this, and that this unity also concerns evil, because evil too is won by this unity.” In his overview of the author, his comment to the poem Mia giovinezza, “the moment when Ada Negri best perceived the reason for her conversion,” is noteworthy, as is the final passage on the poem La verità where the author finds out “that unconditional love is possible, that impossible things become possible”.
The Nature of the “I”—Dante and Saint Paul
Fr. Giussani holds a lesson on the original and ultimate nature of the “I” starting from some suggestions he gathered from the Divine Comedy and Saint Paul’s letters. At the heart of this itinerary is Saint Paul’s statement, “It is no longer I who live, but it is You who live in me,” well describing the fact that the “I” is first and foremost relationship, or Dante’s quote, “The hour / of that good sorrow which to God reweds us,” that is, “to adhere to God as a bride adheres to her bridegroom.” Since the “I” is structurally a companionship, in normal life the awareness of belonging to Christ becomes the awareness of belonging to a people, to the companionship of Christ, and therefore “if companionship originates in a divine initiative, the gaze we need to learn is that of companionship itself.”
Montale, Reason and the Unforeseen
Montale, “a teacher of life since I was a teenager,” is quoted and commented on as a reference point for understanding the question of “reason” (and its possible reduction) and the need for something “unforeseen” that can realize “the expectation of human wisdom.” In reading the poems Perhaps Some Morning and Before the Journey, Fr. Giussani shows how Montale’s great insights are emblematic of the human condition; observing reality leads to the troublesome realization that “things are ephemeral,” that they are seemingly nothing, and thus opens up the great option between nihilism or affirmation of the Mystery— affirmation of the Mystery, and that is a tireless affirmation, even against the manipulations of power, of the category of possibility.
Love Generating What is Human. Reading The Tidings Brought to Mary by Paul Claudel
This reading offers a guide to the work upon which, according to Fr. Giussani, the Movement of Communion and Liberation was born and which represented for him “the greatest poem of this century.” The subject is the very title of the reading, and it is an exploration of both the human attitude for which life flourishes and that which denies it. The discriminating factor is love understood in its true meaning as love “to be for, to be for the Ideal, to be for the whole design, where beauty and justice are safe.” Those who live for love and accept its necessary dimension of sacrifice experience the miracle of something new and of meaning in their daily lives; those who live for love but reduce it to a project, calculation, rejecting its share of pain, live for death. The work is presented by Fr. Giussani as a great dialogue between these two human positions (to which all the main characters can be traced) where only one bears beauty and positivity. Pierre de Craon’s observation, “Why get yourself worked up so much when it is so simple just to obey?” indicates the rule of those who want to live according to the whole design.
The Consciousness of the Church in the Modern World in Choruses from “The Rock” by T. S. Eliot
The reading is a deep consideration of the consciousness of the Church in the world, through Eliot’s poetry and genius; the ultimate issue is his dismaying indictment of “renouncing to Christ, [of] rebelling against Christ and, therefore, [of] eliminating God” and the consequences of this conduct—consequences that are observed in their social and cultural reach. In following Eliot, Fr. Giussani shows the epochal significance of the renunciation of Christ—by renouncing the centrality of the Incarnation, the “cornerstone,” in the name of a “pure sublime,” in fact, a “dangerous heresy” is accomplished in the name of a “perfect society”; an ultimate murderous violence—denying the human being as such, in his carnal imperfection—is accomplished. that denies the human being as such, in his carnal imperfection. The arrogance of those who have forsaken Christ is contrasted with the humility, “God’s first character in man,” of those who accept that they are creatures and depend on a God who became flesh.
Don Giovanni’s Discovery. A Reading from Miguel Mañara by O. V. Milosz
The itinerary on Miguel Mañara by Milosz, “one of the texts that helped to build the beginning of our movement’s history,” develops on four points—the first is centered on the figure of Miguel Mañara, an emblem of the human attempt to satisfy one’s desires by force (the violence and the subsequent desperate cry noted the insufficiency of this attempt); the second concerns the encounter with Girolama, that is a holy and obedient presence, who is capable of true and satisfying possession; the third is the loss, after three months of marriage, of this presence (Girolama dies); the fourth is centered on the encounter with the Abbot who revives Miguel, despite all his weakness, in recognizing the Being who makes everything, Destiny. In this parable, therefore, the true consistency of human love and desire emerges, which can flourish and not die only in grateful obedience to God.
A Voice that Endures in the Darkness. Around the Poems and a Novel by Pär Lagerkvist
This reading considers some poems and the novel Barabbas by author Pär Lagerkvist, whom Fr. Giussani calls “a volcano in his need for meaning” immersed, however, in a pantheistically understood reality—to the urgency for meaning, Lagerkvist seems to respond with an “adogmatic faith, [...] without precisions, corresponding to man’s religious need but without revelation.” In the end, as Fr. Giussani further analyzes, the reality and mystery that Lagerkvist communicates, though “introducing some vibration of life,” is perceived on a purely aesthetic level. But “alongside the aesthetic vibration in which the inevitable attractiveness and suggestion of the mystery of things reverberates, alongside, or rather impending, stands reality’s lack of pity [...]” as if “evil [were] as immortal as good”—finally even the escape from reality, effugium, is countered definitively by the harshness of reality. In this awareness of the datum, Lagerkvist appears to exclude the hypothesis of revelation since he makes no mention of it in any poem. Even his best-known character, Barabbas, who remains a great paradigm of modern man, as Papini suggests, “is the man who has his life saved by Christ and does not know why,” as if to say that revelation no longer seems to have a place on the modern horizon.
Reviving Humanity. Concerning Some Letters by E. Mounier
This reading revolves around some letters showing the grief Mr. And Mrs. Mounier experienced in the face of the severe and permanent illness that occurred to their little daughter Paulette. Through faith, Mounier, “a great Catholic who understood the Christian message to the fullest,” experiences the miracle of overturning one’s limitation and transforming this event into a great call—“faith,” as Fr. Giussani says, “is the hypothesis capable of valuing life and the instant, of transforming death into life and of making creative power out of what would be a burial.” Indeed, the miracle of Christ, as Mounier himself states, goes through Paulette’s offended body, “As I approached her little voiceless bed, I could feel I was approaching an altar, some sacred place where God spoke through a sign.”
Freedom and Gratuitousness. A Look at Two Pages from Charles Péguy
This meditation unfolds the issue of freedom in four points on the basis of some extracts by Charles Péguy. Point number one is a reminder of what freedom is through Péguy’s quote, “A salvation which was not free, which did not come from a free man would mean nothing to us.” As to number two, “the first characteristic of freedom is to recognize an Other to whom we belong.” Number three is that freedom is expressed in “following” the One to whom we belong. Number four, a condition of authentic following, is that it be “a heartfelt attempt to empathize with the deep motives of what is being proposed to you.” Using another passage from Péguy, the theme of gratuitousness is then addressed as the second characteristic of freedom; the French author’s quotation—“Finally, says God, I like that they love, not only freely, but gratuitously”—introduces an issue that will be developed in three points: gratuitousness is wonder and admiration that Christ is the Mystery who makes all things; gratuitousness is availability to His presence, to His companionship; gratuitousness is a glimpse of the truth and therefore a constant asking the great Presence.
Appendix. Three Films
The Impetus of Life. On C. T. Dreyer’s Film Ordet and the Tragedy of Moralism. On the Film Dies Irae (Day of Wrath) by C. T. Dreyer.
The point that Fr. Giussani mainly emphasizes, proposing a reading of these Dreyer films, is the tremendous and dark opposition of “moralism” to life. Within the context of Protestantism, and thus—more or less systematically—of a denial of the Incarnation, the impulse to life and meaning is poorly tolerated and at times violently excluded. Without the strength of a Church that is rooted in the Incarnation, all that remains is the confused and suffering yearning of some who, nevertheless, cannot withstand the pressure of power—“great is the power of evil”—except for a vague concern for the afterlife.
The Concreteness of the Religious Sense. On the Film God Needs Men by J. Delannoy
The three leading facts that Fr. Giussani identifies in this film include the religious sense as the “original sense of an unavoidable, ineradicable, inescapable dependence”; the fact that the religious sense needs man, that it cannot be disembodied, devoid of concrete callings, and that this need to be presence is so alive that, despite all the limitation of the Church, nothing hinders the way, the encounter between God and men—therefore this film “expresses an intelligence of Catholic genius that is rarely found.”